[Next-generation compact multi-amp] VALETON GP-5 vs TONEX ONE: A thorough comparison! The ultimate pocket modeler selected based on sound quality, features, and reviews

Pochip

IK Multimedia TONEX One

TONEX

33,000 JPY(TAX+) (As of 2024:06, March 18, 19 | Rakuten Market research)

Sound House

Pochip

table of contents

\ Going to meet Sound House's sister /

An older sister I often see

Please use Sound House again next time.

GP-5 vs TONEX One｜Spec comparison table

GP-5 vs TONEX One | Features of each model

What is VALETON / GP-5?

Product Features

50 carefully selected amp/pedal profiles included as standard using SnapTone™ (NAM method)
Over 100 high-quality effects built in, with up to 9 blocks available for simultaneous use
Intuitive operation with 1.4-inch color LCD and foot switch with LED ring
20 third-party IR slots + 50 factory preset IRs
Equipped with Bluetooth 5.0/USB-C audio I/F (2IN/2OUT, 44.1kHz)
Built-in 100 drum machine patterns and looper, ideal for practicing and composing
Ultra-compact housing weighing 237 g and 9 cm wide / USB bus-powered
Incredible cost performance with a selling price of around 1.2 yen

The GP-5 is a palm-sized multi-effects and cutting-edge profiling technology packed into a single unit. SnapTone™ can load open source NAM profiles, allowing you to freely play thousands of realistic amp/pedal tones shared around the world.

More than 100 types of effects are recorded and nine blocks can be used simultaneously, so you can create a wide variety of sounds with just one unit. In addition, the color LCD and smartphone app allow you to edit parameters intuitively even though it is a small device. By utilizing Bluetooth audio playback and a drum machine, you can easily create a practice environment.

When connected via USB-C, it functions as a 2-in 2-out audio interface, so it's perfect for home recording. It's amazing how this class of device is packed with so many features, yet is priced at just under 1 yen.

VALETON GP-5

VALETON

Read Reviews

Pochip

What is IK Multimedia / TONEX ONE?

Product Features

AI Machine Modeling "Tone Model" can be saved in 20 slots on the unit
Get free use of over 200 premium models and over 4.5 ToneNET models when you purchase
High quality sound design with 24-bit / 192 kHz AD/DA and 123 dB dynamic range
A/B switching compatible Stomp/Dual 2 modes operated with one foot switch
Quickly adjust EQ, Comp, Gate, and 5 types of reverb with 3 micro knobs
Built-in cabinet IR/IK VIR™ loader, external IR can be freely loaded
USB-C Audio I/F (24-bit/44.1 kHz) & Tone Model Capture
Extremely small aluminum case measuring 48 x 94 mm and 160 g, retail price is about 3 yen

TONEX ONE is an ultra-compact pedal that uses Tone Models that precisely reproduce the behavior of real amps and pedals using AI machine learning. Up to 20 models can be stored on the main unit, and tens of thousands of tones can be freely loaded via the included software and ToneNET.

With 24-bit / 192 kHz high-performance AD / DA and a wide dynamic range of 123 dB, it outputs extremely realistic and high-resolution amp tones. The main unit operation is simple with mini knobs and LED indicators, and A / B switching is also one touch.

It also functions as an audio I/F via USB-C connection, and you can use the capture tool to model your own amps and pedals and carry them around with you. It's the perfect unit for players who want to prioritize sound quality while still covering live performances and home recording in a pocket-sized package.

IK Multimedia TONEX One

TONEX

33,000 JPY(TAX+) (As of 2024:06, March 18, 19 | Rakuten Market research)

Sound House

Pochip

GP-5 vs TONEX One | Differences in sound quality and modeling quality

Key Points

VALETON GP-5

SnapTone™ (NAM method) provides Kemper-level realism at a reduced cost
50 factory profiles + up to 80 user profiles can be saved
50 factory IRs and 20 external IR slots for flexible cabinet switching
100 built-in effects and 9 blocks can be used simultaneously to create the final product

TONEX One

AI Machine Modeling precisely reproduces the harmonics and compression of a vacuum tube amplifier
24-bit / 192 kHz, 123 dB wide dynamic range for high resolution sound
In addition to the premium Tone Models, ToneNET offers expandability with over 4.5 models available
The cabinet can use IK's proprietary VIR™ data or external IR to create a natural feel.

In terms of sound quality, TONEX ONE is designed to aim for the highest peak in both hardware and algorithms. The harmonic output and picking response are just like a tube amp, and the 192 kHz processing and ample headroom of 123 dB capture every nuance. ToneNET allows you to add an endless number of famous machines and artist models, making it advantageous for players who want both variety and realism in their sounds.
Considering its price range, the GP-5 boasts amazing realism, and depending on the NAM profile, you can get a texture that is close to that of the TONEX. Another advantage is that you can output "completed presets" with one unit by configuring up to nine blocks of modulation, delay, etc. There are also a wide variety of cabinet options, so you can create ready-to-use sounds for home recording and streaming. The TONEX is slightly ahead in terms of amp reproduction, while the GP-9 has a slight lead in terms of overall sound making.

GP-5 vs TONEX One | Differences in operability

Key Points

VALETON GP-5

1.4 inch color LCD for complete chain visualization
Only one foot switch, but you can switch modes to control patches, stomp, and tuner
Supports both smartphone apps (BT) and PC editors, allowing wireless editing
Great for practice as you can access drum machines and loopers from the device itself

TONEX One

No display, 1 foot switch, 4 knobs
A simple UI with only two modes: Stomp (ON/OFF) and Dual (A/B switching)
Detailed editing and Tone Model management require TONEX software for PC/Mac
The controls on the unit itself are mainly preset recall and basic EQ/gate/reverb adjustments.

In terms of ease of use, TONEX ONE is designed with the idea of "minimizing operation during live performances." With just one switch you can turn it on/off, or switch between A/B Tone Models, so you can be sure it will work during a live performance without making mistakes when switching pedals. However, since there is no display and it is difficult to make detailed setting changes on-site, it is assumed that you will create your sounds in advance using the TONEX software.
The GP-5 is small but equipped with a visual LCD, and by switching the foot switch mode, you can turn effects on and off and send patches. Editing with a smartphone via Bluetooth is also convenient, and the advantage is that it is easy to fine-tune parameters on stage or in the studio. Since it has a built-in drum machine and looper, it can also function as a practice tool on its own. In summary,If you want simple operation and sound quality, choose the TONEX ONE. If you want quick control over multiple functions, choose the GP-5.It can be said that it is easy to handle.

GP-5 vs TONEX One | User Ratings and Reviews

Good reputation (positive reviews)

Positive reviews

VALETON GP-5

The cost performance is out of this world, with NAM profile support, IR loader, and Bluetooth for just 1 units.
Nine blocks can be used simultaneously, so even though it is small, a single unit can handle all your live presets
Thanks to the built-in drum machine and looper, you can quickly create an environment where you just need to play.
The USB audio I/F function is convenient, and the sound quality of home recording is clearer than expected.
The color LCD makes editing less stressful and even beginners won't get lost.

TONEX One

123 dB wide dynamic range and AI modeling for a three-dimensional sound that is close to the "real amp"
With over 4.5 models on ToneNET, you're almost guaranteed to find the sound you're looking for.
The capture function is revolutionary as it allows you to carry your own amplifier with you
A/B Dual mode is convenient, allowing you to switch between clean and lead with one touch
The aluminum body is sturdy and fits easily into the gaps in your pedal board.

Bad reviews (negative reviews)

Negative reviews

VALETON GP-5

Only one footswitch, so external MIDI is required to switch between multiple effects during a song
When using NAM, there is a restriction that you cannot use an external IR block at the same time, so sound creation takes some effort.
The initial firmware has a somewhat large level difference between patches, so fine tuning is required on site.
Because the body is lightweight, it is easy to slip when stepping on a hard floor.
The PC editor is only available in English, and the Japanese manual is not comprehensive.

TONEX One

Since there is no display, it is difficult to check and edit detailed parameters on-site.
The control system, which switches between multiple functions using small knobs, is a little unreliable on a dark stage.
Since there are volume differences between Tone Models, live presets must be adjusted in advance
The UI of the dedicated software is not intuitive, and there is a learning cost when installing it.
Additional spatial effects cannot be edited immediately, as they require firmware updates.

GP-5 vs TONEX One | Which is best for whom?

VALETON GP-5 is recommended for these people!

Above all, cost performance is the focus
The GP-5 is perfect for those who want a model with as many features as possible on a limited budget. At just over 1 yen a unit, the GP-1 covers everything from multi-effects to profiling amps, making it an unparalleled bargain.
I want an all-in-one small multi-purpose
The GP-5 can be used for a wide range of purposes, from a tabletop multi-player for home practice to a portable session player, or even as a backup for large equipment. The built-in drum machine and Bluetooth playback function make it a great companion for solo practice, and the headphone jack means you can play without hesitation even at night.
Use a variety of effects
The GP-5 is perfect for those who want to enjoy creating sounds by combining multiple effects such as spatial and modulation effects. By using nine blocks simultaneously, you can freely arrange the amps, cabs, and effects, allowing you to fully unleash your creativity. Although it is condensed into a compact body, it also supports editing with smartphone apps, so detailed settings are also smooth.
I want to link with MIDI and other devices.
Although unofficially, the GP-5 supports MIDI control via USB, allowing you to remotely switch patches and turn effects on/off with an external foot switch (MIDI controller). It can also be used flexibly as the centerpiece of a small effects board, combining it with other pedals.
Feel free to try out the latest technology
The GP-5 is also a good choice for those who are interested in the latest amp modeling technology such as NAM, but are hesitant to spend money on expensive equipment. Thanks to open source, you can try out many profiles that are distributed for free, so you can easily experience the world of digital amplifiers.

TONEX One is recommended for these people!

You want an extremely realistic amp sound
TONEX ONE is perfect for guitarists who prioritize sound quality above all else, and for whom the most important thing when creating a sound is the texture of the amp. The vividness of the sound produced by AI modeling is guaranteed, and the joy of playing the sound of a classic instrument at home is hard to beat. Even for recording purposes, it is said to produce a tone that approaches that of a live amp recording.
I want to have a wide range of amps
Even if you're greedy and want all the Marshalls, Fenders, and Mesas, with TONEX ONE you can get new models one after another via ToneNET. The real joy of TONEX is that you can collect everything from vintage amps you couldn't afford to buy to the sounds of professional artists with just one pocket-sized pedal. In fact, many users get so addicted to exploring ToneNET that they end up spending the whole night trying out different Tone Models.
I want to combine it with a hand-held pedal.
If you already have a few favorite effect pedals, placing TONEX ONE at the end of your pedal board and using it as an amp and cabinet simulator is also an effective way to do so. Selecting a clean amp model and using a distortion pedal to create your sound is an intuitive way to use it during a live performance. TONEX ONE itself has the bare minimum of gate, compression, and reverb built in, so you can use other pedals to fill in the gaps and make it function as a "small amp head."
I want to carry my own amplifier
Have you ever wished you could take your favorite amp or drive pedal to a gig? With TONEX ONE, you can do just that with the included software. Although you will need additional equipment such as a reamp box, once you've created a cloned tone, all you need to do is bring TONEX ONE. It's perfect for players who want to recreate their familiar sounds anywhere while significantly reducing the burden of transporting equipment.
Seeking future growth potential
TONEX ONE is part of IK's TONEX ecosystem, and has the potential for future software updates and compatibility with higher-end models. For example, even if you move to the more user-friendly "TONEX Pedal" (larger version) in the future, the Tone Model assets you've created will not go to waste. It can also be used with other IK products such as AmpliTube, so it's also suitable for people who want to enrich their DTM and digital environments.

The VALETON GP-5 and IK Multimedia TONEX ONE are both excellent compact model instruments that represent modern guitar technology.

The GP-5 stands out for its versatility and ease of use, "it's palm-sized and can do anything," while the TONEX ONE exudes the charm of an artisan, "it's small but doesn't compromise on sound." Although each has a different approach, they both share the same goal: to condense the sound and functionality of large equipment into an extremely small pedal.

Which one you should choose depends on the use and sound you are looking for. If you want to enjoy creative sound creation using a wide range of effects, the GP-5 will be your reliable companion, and if you want to improve your playing with the best amp tone, the TONEX ONE will meet your expectations.

Both models have been praised by Guitar Magazine for their performance and offer value far beyond their price. Thanks to digital technology, we are faced with the happy dilemma of being able to choose such excellent tools. GP-5 or TONEX ONE? The answer is different for each person, but no matter which one you get, new inspiration and the best sound are sure to await you. Please check out their capabilities at the venue and decide which one is the best for you.

VALETON GP-5

VALETON

Read Reviews

Pochip

IK Multimedia TONEX One

TONEX

33,000 JPY(TAX+) (As of 2024:06, March 18, 19 | Rakuten Market research)

Sound House